This indicator has been retired and is no longer reported.
This standard was retired on May 23, 2018, as part of the Threshold Update Initiative: Reorganization and Non‐Policy Technical Corrections. See the Governing Board staff report at https://www.trpa.gov/wp-content/uploads/documents/archive/May-23-2018-Governing-Board-Packet-Final.pdf for more information. The content on this page is archived and available for evaluations prior to May 2018, but will not be updated or maintained for future evaluations.
Pope Marsh is include in the Threshold Dashboard. Threshold Indicators are evaluated against Threshold Standards every 4 years. Thresholds are environmental goals and standards for the Lake Tahoe Basin that indirectly define the capacity of the Region to accommodate additional land development.
Status
Pope Marsh
By:
No reported data for this Indicator
Evaluation Map
Location of Pope Marsh and surrounding area.
2015 Evaluation
Status
Insufficient Data to Determine Status or No Target Established
Provide for the nondegradation of the natural qualities of any plant community that is uncommon to the Basin or of exceptional scientific, ecological, or scenic value. This threshold shall apply but not be limited to 8) Pope Marsh.
Key Points
No Key Points
About the Threshold
Pope Marsh occupies roughly 1,500 acres adjacent to the City of South Lake Tahoe, and is managed by U.S. Forest Service Lake Tahoe Basin Management Unit (LTBMU). It was formerly part of the wetland complex at the mouth of the Upper Truckee River, but development of the Tahoe Keys in the 1960s isolated Pope Marsh from the Upper Truckee River and dramatically reduced the size of what was the largest freshwater marsh and meadow complex in the Sierra Nevada (Manley et al. 2000). Pope Marsh is now dependent primarily on rain, snowmelt, and underground flow from Lake Tahoe for its water (Green 1991). Meadows, marshes, and fens have been identified in the Tahoe Science Plan (Manley et al., 2010) as special communities that are small in extent but have great functional importance. Wetland vegetation plays an important role in recycling nutrients, trapping eroding soil, and filtering pollutants (Manley et al. 2000). This filtration capacity is critically important to protect the clarity of Lake Tahoe. Pope Marsh also provides important habitat for numerous species, including waterfowl nesting habitat.
Pope Marsh was irreversibly altered by the development of the Tahoe Keys (Manley et al. 2000).Since then, human activities outside of the marsh (e.g. groundwater pumping, development, and management of lake water levels) impact hydrology within the marsh (Green 1991). The sandy beach deposits that divide Pope Marsh from Lake Tahoe allow for rapid groundwater flow; therefore, the northern portion of Pope Marsh fills and drains in relation to surface elevation of Lake Tahoe. When the level of Lake Tahoe is low, Pope Marsh drains and becomes dry. Based on the presence and depth of peat within Pope Marsh, it is theorized that historically Pope Marsh received water flow in late summer and fall, and sustained saturated conditions throughout the year even when the lake level of Lake Tahoe was lower (before the dam was built). The southern portion of Pope Marsh is less influenced by lake levels, and relies primarily on snowmelt and upland stream flow processes. These anthropogenic stresses on Pope Marsh increase sensitivity to naturally occurring stressors, and likely will initiate gradual changes in the plant community composition of the marsh, which could dramatically change the effectiveness of the marsh as a filter of nutrients and sediments (Green, 1991). In 2011, a high precipitation year, water from Pope Marsh breached the sand berm and flowed into Lake Tahoe. Other human impacts include the introduction of invasive plants, dogs, and some trampling from hiking and bicycling
Similar to other wetlands, extended drought and climate change pose a threat to the system. Recent California based climate models predict a nine-degree Fahrenheit increase in temperature by 2100, and more conservative models predict a two- to four-degree Fahrenheit increase in winter and four- to eight- degree Fahrenheit increase in summer (Safford et al., 2012a). Models are more variable for precipitation, but recent models for the Sierra Nevada predict similar to slightly less precipitation. Most models predict drier summer conditions, since more of the precipitation is predicted to come as rain, and snow melt-off will occur earlier in spring (Hayhoe et al. 2004, Dettinger 2005, Safford et al. 2012, Drexler et al. 2013). In the Lake Tahoe Region, these changes appear to be happening at an accelerated pace (Coats 2010). These changes will likely result in decreased stream flow and increased stream temperatures in the summer and fall (Purdy et al. 2014). Climate change may create larger or more frequent flood events if more precipitation comes as rain instead of snow, but will create drier conditions in summer and fall due to lack of slow melting snow pack. Prolonged drought can lower water tables in meadows, increasing the area dominated by drier upland grasses and forbs, and reduce the presence of less resistant and resilient obligate wetland plants (Rejmankova et al. 1999). During the drought of 1988 to 1994, vegetation changes were monitored in Pope Marsh. The results revealed an overall decline in plant production, relative stability in the area dominated by sedge (Carex sp.) and rush (Juncus sp.) communities, and a decline in Rocky Mountain pond-lily (Nuphar lutea subsp. polysepala) and hardstem bulrush (Schoenoplectus acutus) communities. Most species recovered quickly after the drought, but hardstem bulrush did not. An increase in diversity was observed, as forbs such as common mare’s tail (Hippuris vulgaris) and other ruderal terrestrial species established in dry pond margins (Rejmankova et al. 1999).
Insufficient data to determine status. Pope Marsh is adjacent to Pope Beach, which is one of the most heavily used public recreation facilities at Lake Tahoe in the summer months. Most of the use is concentrated on the beach itself, but a long parking lot separates Pope Marsh from Lake Tahoe and culverts connect the beach area to the marsh. The main impacts to the marsh are related to recreation, including disturbance of vegetation and wildlife by dogs and some trampling from hiking and bicycling. A relatively large infestation of bull thistle (Cirsium vulgare) has been present at Pope Marsh for several years, and Eurasian watermilfoil (Myriophyllum spicatum) occurs in the standing water. Groundwater pumping from the Tahoe Keys potentially poses a threat to the hydrologic regime, and is likely leading to a gradual change in species composition (Green, 1991).
The potential for decline from increased recreational impacts or an increase in non-native species was noted (TRPA 2007). Management actions in the last five years have focused on facility improvements, hazard tree removal at Pope Beach, and control of known invasive plant populations at Pope Marsh. The location of the wetland in the urban core, and the associated urban run-off and invasive plant infestations suggest that the natural qualities of Pope Marsh are not as intact as more remote wetlands like Hell Hole or Meiss Meadows. Groundwater pumping from the Tahoe Keys is an ongoing threat to the integrity of the marsh plant community (Green 1991). The effects of the recent drought on Pope Marsh are unknown. There is no recent quantitative or qualitative data available, so the status of Pope Marsh is unknown.
Trend Rationale
Insufficient data to determine trend. The 2011 Threshold Evaluation Report considered Pope Marsh to be somewhat worse than target. No further evidence is available to indicate a change in the trend in the last four years.
Confidence Details
Confidence of Status
Low. Where insufficient data is available to determine status the confidence is determined to be low.
Confidence of Trend
Low. Where insufficient data is available to determine trend the confidence is determined to be low.