This indicator measures regional visibility on the "worst" days of the year at non-urban areas in the Tahoe Basin. Visibility measures the distance at which an object or light can be clearly discerned by the human eye. Sources of locally generated haze pollutants include entrained/suspended roadway particles, vehicle emissions, residential wood burning, campfires, prescribed fires, and wildfires. Some particles responsible for the degradation of regional visibility in the Tahoe Basin include dust and other pollutants transported into the Basin from areas as far as Asia, and record-setting catastrophic wildfires throughout California and the western states in the last five years. Regional programs such as decreasing the number of polluting wood stoves and work to improve forest health aim to increase regional visibility. Regional visibility is monitored at DL Bliss State Park as part of the national IMPROVE monitoring network.
Status
Regional visibility conditions monitored at the DL Bliss IMPROVE monitoring station.
Interagency Monitoring of Protected Visual Environments, UC Davis Air Quality Research Center
Evaluation Map
Regional visibility monitoring station at DL Bliss State Park.
AQ6: Achieve an extinction coefficient of 34 Mm-1 at least 90 percent of the time as calculated from aerosol species concentrations measured at the Bliss State Park monitoring site (visual range of 115 kilometers, 71 miles).
Key Points
The 90th percentile value of the regional visibility indicator has exceeded the threshold value, after a steady increase from the minimum in 2013.
Organic mass is the dominant contributor to the reduced visibility, suggesting the increasing trend in days with poor visibility is due to the impact of wildfire (TRPA Ambient Air Monitoring Program, DRI 2023).
Data shows a long term improvement in median visibility (50% visibility), but an increase in hazy periods (90% visibility).
While emissions controls on anthropogenic pollutant emissions appears to be improving visibility, increased intensity and duration of wildfire has led to reduced visibility on the haziest days. (USDA 2024)
In 1977, the U.S. Congress amended the federal Clean Air Act to include a national goal to remedy any existing visibility impairment and prevent any future visibility degradation in large national parks and federal wilderness areas. The goal is to return visibility to natural conditions which includes events such as wildfire. (California's Regional Haze Plan, 2022)
About the Threshold
This indicator measures regional visibility and the distance that the human eye can see. It is measured by using a reconstructed light extinction (bext) value, which is derived from an equation that combines measured concentrations of several gasses and particles. The equation is corrected for humidity and natural “background” light scattering. Bext is summarized by “average visibility days” (50th percentile values) and “worst visibility days” (90th percentile values) for each year, followed by calculating the 3-year running average. This threshold standard has been adopted to protect regional visibility and air quality.
Particulate matter in the atmosphere is the primary driver of visibility impairment because of the optical properties and long retention times in the air (Green et al. 2011, 201). The main sources of particulate matter in the basin are residential and wildfire smoke, and entrained roadway dust (DRI 2011a). Effective motor vehicle tail pipe emission controls, residential wood combustion controls, appropriately managed prescribed burning, and road dust emission control aid in improving regional visibility conditions (Chen, Watson, and Wang 2011). There is uncertainty related to visibility condition in the future due to predicted increases in frequency and intensity of wildfires in the western U.S.
This project, completed in 2018, included hazardous fuel reduction and forest ecosystem health treatments on approximately 3,100 acres of the east shore of the Lake Tahoe Basin.
This plan focuses on infrastructure for plug-in electric vehicles within the Tahoe-Truckee Region because they play a critical role in reducing the GHG emissions of vehicles.
Visibility monitoring data are collected, analyzed, and reported by the IMPROVE (national Interagency Monitoring of Protected Environments) network using nationally accepted protocols.
Rationale Details
Status Rationale
Considerably Worse Than Target. The status is based on the 3-year running average of the reconstructed light-extinction (Mm-1) from data collected at the D.L. Bliss monitoring site. In 2023, the 3-year running average was 53.9, 158% of the not to exceed standard. Therefore, the status is considered, considerably worse than target.
Trend Rationale
Moderate Decline. Trend is determined using the 3-year running average of the reconstructed light-extinction (Mm-1) from data collected at the D.L. Bliss monitoring site. The percent change relative to the standard is 0.85%, therefore the trend is moderate decline.
Confidence Details
Confidence of Status
High. Monitoring is conducted using strict protocols and there is a long data set to analyze trend.
Confidence of Trend
Low. Confidence of trend is determined by the duration of trustworthy data and both the coefficient of determination and t-test significance. There is a long term trustworthy dataset for air quality. R²= 0.1368 (low), p-value= 0.2938, according to the trend methodology, the trend has low confidence.
Overall Confidence
Moderate. If one confidence rating is high and the other is low, the overall confidence rating is moderate.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) promulgated visibility protection rules that established state implementation plan (SIP) requirements for states to address sources of visibility impairment and improve visibility to natural conditions by 2064. Under these rules, the California Air Resources Board (CARB) is required to develop a Regional Haze Plan every 10 years addressing the visibility in wilderness areas including portions of the Lake Tahoe Basin.