This indicator tracks the transparency of Lake Tahoe as measured by the annual average Secchi depth at the Lake Tahoe Index Station. Restoring Lake Tahoe's transparency is important to maintaining both ecological function, and its values to local and regional economies as a recreational destination and drinking water source. The decline in transparency is a result of the additions of fine sediment particles and the growth of phytoplankton (algae). Drivers influencing the delivery of fine sediment and nutrients include urban development, anthropogenic and natural disturbance in the undeveloped portions of the watershed and local and regional climate. Many programs throughout the Tahoe Region are aimed at improving lake clarity such as stormwater reduction and stream restoration projects. Lake clarity has been measured at Lake Tahoe by UC Davis since 1968. 

secchi-disk-lake-tahoe-1024x768.jpg

Photo Credit: UC Davis

Status

Average annual Secchi depth from the Lake Tahoe Index Station as taken by UC Davis.

Evaluation Map

Water clarity monitoring stations.

2023 Evaluation

Status
Somewhat Worse Than Target
Trend
Little or No Change
Confidence
Moderate
View Evaluation

Applicable Standard

WQ1: The annual average deep water transparency as measured by Secchi disk shall not be decreased below 29.7 meters (97.4 feet), the average levels recorded between 1967 and 1971 by the University of California, Davis.

Key Points

  • Tahoe's famed clarity declined by nearly a foot a year between the late 1960s and 2000. Annual average clarity has remained relatively stable since 2000, but has not shown signs of improvement. Summer clarity continues to show a statistically significant decline (Smits 2024, Forrest & Watanabe 2024). 
  • Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) implementors (CalTrans, Nevada Dept. of Transportation, City of South Lake Tahoe, Douglas County, El Dorado County, Placer County, and Washoe County) collectively, prevent 600,000 pounds per year of fine sediment from reaching the lake (2023 TMDL Performance Report).
  • During the four year evaluation period TMDL implementors exceeded load reduction targets by 8 percent, obtaining 11,319 credits relative to a target of 10,528. Implementors have exceeded annual load reduction targets in seven of the last eight years. In 2023 implementors fell just short, achieving 98 percent of the load reduction target. Additional details: https://clarity.laketahoeinfo.org/Results/Detail/UrbanUplands
  • The Tahoe Science Advisory Council completed a review of the pelagic water quality monitoring program in July 2024. The primary recommendations were, 1) maintain current monitoring, 2) augment data management, 3) expand geographic sampling, and 4) expand ecological monitoring. Tahoe Science Advisory Council review of Lake Tahoe monitoring
  • The winter of 2022-2023 had the sixth-highest snowpack in the 144-year record of the UC Berkeley Central Sierra Snow Lab (https://cssl.berkeley.edu/). The influx of particles from the watershed following snowmelt caused a dramatic drop in clarity. Clarity measured mid snowmelt was 8 meters on May 24, 2023, the lowest ever recorded in Tahoe monitoring.
  • Tahoe Science Advisory Council Understanding Lake Tahoe Water Clarity explainer.
  • Individual measurements can be downloaded from the EDI portal.

About the Threshold

This indicator tracks the transparency of Lake Tahoe as measured by the annual average Secchi depth at the Lake Tahoe Index Station. To restore Lake Tahoe’s historic transparency and clarity and protect its special status designations, the states of California and Nevada collaborated to develop a water quality restoration plan and jointly administer the Lake Tahoe Total Maximum Daily Load Program (TMDL). The protection of Lake Tahoe’s transparency is a key component of the Regional Plan, and a priority focus of the Environmental Improvement Program. Restoring Lake Tahoe's transparency is important to maintaining both ecological function, and its values to local and regional economies as a recreational destination and drinking water source. This standard is also codified in the Bi-State Lake Tahoe TMDL.
Water transparency in Lake Tahoe is largely controlled by particles in the 1– 15 µm size range blocking light penetration either by scattering or absorption. The decline in transparency is a result of the additions of fine sediment particles and the growth of phytoplankton (algae). The TMDL estimated that fine sediment particles (FSP) are responsible for about two-thirds of the overall decline in transparency. The primary source of fine sediment particles in the lake is stormwater runoff, which accounts for 72 percent of the total load. Additional sources include atmospheric deposition (15 percent) and non-urban uplands (nine percent) and stream channel erosion (four percent). Algal growth is stimulated by nutrient (nitrogen and phosphorus) loading from stream and stormwater runoff and atmospheric deposition. Drivers influencing the delivery of fine sediment and nutrients include urban development (including the transportation network and vehicle density), anthropogenic and natural disturbance in the undeveloped portions of the watershed, and local and regional climate (especially wind and precipitation). Below average stream inflows and stormwater runoff due to the continuing drought are substantial contributing factors in the recent improvement of lake transparency. The composition of diatom communities also influences clarity. When communities are dominated by smaller size diatoms, clarity is reduced because smaller diatoms remain in suspension longer, thus continuing to scatter light and decrease clarity. Lake mixing also influences clarity. The deeper waters of Lake Tahoe are very clear. During mixing events, when deep waters are brought up the surface, clarity is often quite high. However, mixing also brings nutrients to the surface which promotes algae growth which can reduce clarity. Climate change has the potential to alter the depth and frequency of mixing. An altered mixing regime may further influence the algal composition in the lake. A 2022 Tahoe Science Advisory Council review of factors that influence clarity suggested that clarity was most impacted by particles in the 1.00–4.76 µm size range. The 2023 annual clarity report from UC Davis suggested future research explore the impact of microplastics on clarity. Work to date has confirmed the presence of microplastics in Tahoe, but additional research is necessary to understand the concentration in the size range that most impacts clarity. Research into the causes of the continued decline in summer clarity is ongoing, but preliminary work suggests that both climate change and ecological change are impacting clarity. The 2023 annual clarity report from UC Davis suggested future research explore the impact of microplastics on clarity. Work to date has confirmed the presence of microplastics in Tahoe, but additional research is necessary to understand the concentration in the size range that most impacts clarity. The difference in seasonal trends that the Tahoe Science Advisory Council first highlighted in 2020 continued in the last four years. While no significant trend is visible for annual clarity, summer clarity continues to decline and winter clarity is improving. Research into the causes of the continued decline in summer clarity is ongoing, but preliminary work suggests that both climate change and aquatic invasive species are impacting clarity.

Delivering and Measuring Success

Example EIP Projects

Lake Clarity Indicators

Local and Regional Plans

  • Lake Tahoe TMDL

    The Lake Tahoe TMDL Program is a science-based plan with stormwater load reduction for implementers to reinstate historic clarity levels in Lake Tahoe.

Monitoring Programs

Rationale Details

Somewhat Worse Than Target. In 2023 the annual average decreased to 20.8 meters (68 feet) from 21.9 meters (72 feet) in 2022. 2023 also followed the trend observed in recent years. The Tahoe TMDL established an interim target, dubbed the "Clarity Challenge", of 78 feet in 2026. Because of inter-annual variability in clarity, TMDL milestones are assessed against the five-year running average. The most recent five-year average (2019-2023) was 65 feet. The most recent five-year average is 19% below the interim target of 78 feet, with three years of implementation remaining before the start of the interim target assessment period. The current status assessed against the interim target is somewhat worse than target.
Little or No Change. Analysis by the Tahoe Science Advisory Council of the long-term trend suggests that the statistically significant decline in annual average readings occurred between 1968 and 1998. Since that time there has been no statistically significant trend in the annual average Secchi depths.

Confidence Details

High. There is high confidence in the status determination. Secchi depth measurements are used widely as a measure of water transparency in oceans and lakes. It is a reliable, relatively simple, and inexpensive measurement of lake transparency. It is among the oldest limnological devices and was first used by Italian Professor P.A. Secchi in the 1860s. Jassby et al. (1999) evaluated the general precision of the method used in Lake Tahoe, and estimated the average precision based on two observers was +0.027 m (Jassby et al., 1999). An analysis of annual average Secchi depth readings (includes water conditions down to a depth of approximately 20 meters in recent years) and the vertical extinction coefficient (a more sophisticated electronic sensor for measuring light levels down approximately 100 meters), has shown these two measures of light penetration in Lake Tahoe to be well correlated over the entire period of record (UC Davis - TERC, 2011).
Moderate. The long-term trend is estimated using a generalized additive model, which blends properties of generalized linear models and additive models. While statistically significant declines in the annual average Secchi depth have not been observed since 1998, summer clarity continues to show a statistically significant decline. Recent work by the science community has highlighted the impacts of ecology, climate change, and plastics on lake clarity.
Moderate. If one confidence rating is high and the other is moderate, the overall confidence rating is the lower confidence rating.

Additional Figures and Resources


2023 Lake Tahoe Clarity Report
Uploaded On
8/3/2024
File Type
PDF
Description
UC-Davis TERC 2023 report on clarity of Lake Tahoe.
Interannual trends, seasonal patterns in long-term Secchi depth (Smits, 2024)
Uploaded On
10/24/2024
File Type
PDF
Description
Examination of interannual trends, seasonal patterns, and residual variation in the long-term Secchi depth record at Lake Tahoe. Dr. Adrianne Smits, Dept. Environmental Science and Policy, University of California Davis, Davis, CA, 95616 This work was coordinated by the Tahoe Science Advisory Council.